Contrary Contrarianism<br />By Rev Shark<br />RealMoney.com Contributor<br />6/11/2010 8:55 AM EDT<br /><br /> Whoever said money can't buy happiness simply didn't know where to go shopping.<br /> -- Bo Derek<br /><br />Despite some mixed economic data out of China, overseas markets are mostly in positive territory. But retail sales are out and are well below estimates. In fact, they're the worst numbers in eight months, and the poor numbers are going to be a headwind this morning. Many people have wondered how this economy could continue to support consumer spending; the data this morning suggest that maybe it isn't.<br /><br />Obviously the big question now is whether we can build on yesterday's strength and test the big technical level around 1105-1107 of the S&P 500, which is the 200-day simple moving average and the place where the last two rally attempts have failed. Volume was light, which makes it more difficult to trust in the likelihood of sustained momentum, but I don't expect the bears to make much of a stand until we move closer to that 1105 area.<br /><br />The BP (BP) situation has cooled off and the stock is bidding up again this morning despite news that the estimates of how much oil is leaking have been low. Oil-related stocks led the bounce yesterday and look to be off to a good start again this morning. Many of them are still extremely oversold, so they have the capacity to provide a tailwind if the Gulf situation stabilizes a little more.<br /><br />One interesting thing about the spike yesterday was that I didn't see anyone predicting that we have seen the lows. Typically when we bounce after a sharp pullback, we will hear plenty of chatter about how the worst is over and how it is clear sailing from here.<br /><br />Those with a contrarian bent would say that is a good thing. Their logic is that the market seldom does what everyone thinks it will. The theory is that when everyone is in agreement about something, that means they will have already acted on that belief and there are few left to keep things moving.<br /><br />In the present case, if everyone believes that we haven't seen a bottom, then they are likely to be holding higher levels of cash and will inch into the market and hold it up should it not pull back quickly, as anticipated. It creates a "wall of worry" situation where no one trusts the rally but they have cash and don't want to miss out, so that holds us up.<br /><br />The problem with most contrarian thinking about the market is that it usually is quite subjective and not very precise. Trying to gauge what "everyone" is thinking and doing are not easy tasks.<br /><br />Most of the time, the crowd is right. That is why we have trends that last so long. Even when everyone sounds bullish, we can easily keep on going as they find new cash to plow into the market. It is only at real extremes that the crowd is wrong -- and that doesn't occur that often.<br /><br />At this point I don't think we have enough extremes for contrarian thinking to work very well. The crowd is still adjusting to the change in market character that has evolved over the past month, and news like this retail sales number shows the concerns of the crowd are not unrealistic.<br /><br />We have had quite a bit of choppy action lately and it looks like we are for more now as we grapple with this retail data, which is causing gold to spike and oil to falter. <br />-----------------------------------<br />Briefing.com vahendusel:<br />Ülespoole avanevad:<br /><br />In reaction to strong earnings/guidance: MCZ +20.5%, ARST +10.5%, FNSR +3.6%.<br /><br />M&A news: MDNU+40.3% (light volume; Danone to acquire Medical Nutrition USA for $4.00/share in cash), BGH +18.7% (Buckeye Partners, LP and Buckeye GP Holdings LP announce merger agreement; BGH unitholders to receive ~$41.00/unit in BPL stock).<br /><br />Select financial related names showing strength: STD +6.3% (Banco Santander Central's Botin says expects earnings in 2010 to be similar to those of 2009 ), BBVA +4.0%, UBS +2.7%, CS +2.0%.<br /><br />Select oil/gas related names showing strength: BP +5.9% (rebounding in overseas trading; National Incident Commander Admiral Thad Allen sent a letter to BP Chairman requesting meeting with Obama on June 16), APC +2.2% , RIG +1.6%.<br /><br />Select drug related names trading higher: BMY +2.7% (upgraded to Buy from Hold at Citigroup; upgraded to Outperform from Market Perform at Leerink Swann), NVS +2.8% (FDA advisory committee unanimously recommends approval of Novartis investigational treatment FTY720 to treat relapsing remitting MS), PFE +2.0%, GSK +1.2% and AZN + 1.0% (Hearing early strength attributed to upgrade at tier 1 firm).<br /><br />Other news: WEN +10.1% (Funds recently received an oral inquiry from a third party expressing interest on a preliminary basis in a potential acquisition involving the Co, which could include the Filing Persons' participation), XIDE +8.0% (announces new licensing agreement with Honeywell consumer products group), DCTH +3.3% (light volume; will hold conf call to report corp updates and Phase III trial data comparing percutaneous hepatic perfusion with melphalan on Jun 15), MOT +2.6% (Motorola and Research In Motion (RIMM) announce settlement and license agreement ), RIMM +0.8% (Motorola and Research In Motion (RIMM) announce settlement and license agreement ), .<br /><br />Analyst comments: SQNM +4.4% (upgraded to Buy from Hold at Auriga), STZ +2.9% (initiated with a Buy at Citigroup), AEO +2.7% (upgraded to Buy from Hold at Jefferies).<br /><br />Allapoole avanevad:<br /><br />M&A news: BPL -6.9% (Buckeye Partners, LP and Buckeye GP Holdings LP announce merger agreement; BGH unitholders to receive ~$41.00/unit in BPL stock),.<br /><br />Select financial related names showing lower: COF -2.2%, BCS -1.9% , RBS -1.8% , AIB -2.2% , IRE -2.2%, LYG -2.1%, SNV -1.9%, RF -1.7%, JPM -1.5%, C -1.2%, WFC -1.2%, BAC -1.0%.<br /><br />Select mortgage insurer related names pulling back: PMI -2.9%, MBI -2.7%, AIG -1.6%, MTG -1.4%<br /><br />Select metals/mining stocks trading lower: RTP -3.6%, MT -2.4%, BHP -1.9%, VALE -1.3%, GFI -1.2%, AU -1.2%.<br /><br />Other news: CMO -4.2% (Capstead Mortgage declares Q2 dividend of $0.36/share, down from prior $0.50/share), DELL -2.7% (files NT10-Q, notification of late filing; has revised financial results that were reported in the earnings release to record a $100 million liability for the potential settlement of the SEC investigation), AGU -2.3% (Hearing early weakness attributed to tier 1 form downgrade), MO -1.6% (trading ex dividend), SLB -1.2% (announced the effect on its US operations following the recently announced six-month Minerals Management Service ).<br /><br />Analyst comments: FSLR -3.2% (initiated with a Sell at Cantor), WAG -1.2% (downgraded to Market Weight from Overweight at Thomas Weisel), THO -0.8% (continued weakness from the intraday drop in reaction to earnings; downgraded to Hold from Buy at Soleil).