Do We Trust Yesterday's Rally?<br />By Rev Shark<br />RealMoney.com Contributor<br />9/2/2010 8:26 AM EDT <br /><br />"It is better to debate a question without settling it than to settle a question without debating it." <br /><br />-- Joseph Joubert <br />The question for us to ponder this morning is whether the big move on Thursday was a one-day wonder or the start of a change in the character of the market. We have been in a downtrend since the end of April, but despite a couple good-sized bounces since then, we have not been able to shift back to an uptrend. The bulls say we are ready to start on the road to recovery, but the bears say don't be too quick to think that the worst is over. <br /><br />The two biggest positives the bulls have going for them right now is that sentiment has been extremely negative and earnings reports last quarter were generally quite good. Sentiment is one of those contrary indicators that can be quite tricky to use and difficult to time. The thinking is that when market players are extremely negative, they have most likely already sold their stocks, and, therefore, selling pressure is likely to come to an end. <br /><br />The problem is that we really have no way of knowing if market players are acting on their bearish beliefs. I know investors who say they are bearish yet are still 95% long. Most market players are a bit more consistent, and, at some point, extreme negativity does tend to be a valid contrary indicator. We just don't know what the catalyst might be for investors to realize that they are unduly pessimistic. <br /><br />Earnings reports are probably the most persuasive bullish argument for this market. We had very solid second-quarter reports, and if you didn't know that the economy was struggling, you would think things were pretty positive if you just looked at earnings. The problem is that quite a few stocks, especially in the semiconductor sector, acted poorly following their reports. Some market players believe that we have seen peak earnings and that estimates have gotten too high. If estimates prove to be correct, however, there are some very good values out there that should see positive action as third-quarter numbers approach. <br /><br />The bears' best argument right now is very obvious. It is the technical condition of the charts. We have been in a downtrend for a while, there have been a number of failed bounces since the top in April, and we still have plenty of overhead resistance to deal with as we enter a weak time of the year. The bulls have the burden of proof here, and it is going to take more than one big day of gains to shift the tide. <br /><br />The struggling economy is also supportive of the bearish view. The ISM number was the first clearly positive economic data point that we have seen in a while. Employment and housing have been consistently poor, and there are no signs that they are going to suddenly improve. Maybe that is already priced into the market, at least to some extent, and we'll know better as we see the response to the reports that are coming up. <br /><br />We have weekly unemployment claims this morning and the monthly jobs reports tomorrow, so the focus is going to shift back to employment and ISM will be quickly forgotten. If we don't see some signs of improvement in jobs soon, it is going to be very tough for the bulls to maintain much optimism. <br /><br />Longer term, the election in November is going to be very important for the market. If we can achieve gridlock in Washington, it is likely to be a positive for the market. Extension of the Bush tax cuts is going to be difficult, however, because they will expire automatically if no action is taken. The market clearly favors the extension of these cuts for everyone, so that could be a problem down the road if there isn't bipartisan support for them. <br /><br />Overall, the bears have the edge in this struggle simply because the technical picture is still quite dreary. The gains yesterday were a good start for a turn back up, but there is no reason to believe that it was anything other than a beginning-of-the-month hiccup driven by inflows, too much negativity and oversold conditions. The bulls have much tougher work to do if they are really going to turn this market up, and the first big hurdle is going to be dealing with the lousy employment picture. <br /><br />We have a mild positive start shaping up this morning. Asia played catch-up with our gains overnight, and Europe is mixed. Data at 8:30 a.m. EDT will help establish the tone for the day. <br />-----------------------------<br />Ülespoole avanevad:<br /><br />In reaction to strong earnings/guidance: HWD +17.0%, COST +1.1% (light volume), SAI +0.8%. <br /><br />M&A news: BKC +22.0% (Faber reports that Burger King will be acquired by 3G for $24/share), DTG +1.1% (AVIS Increases Premium Offer to $40.75 from $39.25 for Dollar Thrifty). <br /><br />Other news: GRMH +23.9% (reaches definitive agreement with Walgreens to sell assets of 18 ApothecaryRx pharmacies; terms not disclosed), OREX +15.5% (Orexigen Therapeutics and Takeda enter into partnership to commercialize Contrave in North America), CRME +13.1% (Cardiome Pharma and Merck announce that the nitravenous formulation of BRINAVESS has been granted marketing approval in the EU, Iceland and Norway), WEN +6.3% (trading higher in sympathy with BKC), MAIL +5.1% (approved 2010 interim cash dividend of $0.45/share), MPEL +4.9% (ticking higher in premarket; Hearing move attributed to tier 1 upgrade), BRCD (continued strength following yesterday's takeover chatter), CGV +2.0% (still checking for anything specific), ASML +1.6% (still checking), WSC +1.4% (announces formation of special committee of Board of Directors). <br /><br />Analyst comments: VTG +2.9% (initiated with a Buy at Jefferies), CLWR +2.3% (initiated with Buy at Kaufman Brothers).<br /><br />Allapoole avanevad:<br /><br />Gapping down: PSS -7.7%, MATK -2.5%, PDE -1.5%.