Wishing for More Negativism Before Rita<br />9/23/2005 9:18 AM EDT<br /><br />"Hope is the most sensitive part of a poor wretch's soul; whoever raises it only to torment him is behaving like the executioners in Hell who, they say, incessantly renew old wounds and concentrate their attention on that area of it that is already lacerated." <br /><br />-- Marquis De Sade <br /><br />Downgrades aren't usually a reason for hope but the downgrade in Hurricane Rita yesterday to a Category 4 was enough to convince some buyers that maybe they should be optimistic about the impact. This morning crude oil is down about 60 cents as I write, even though the projected path of the hurricane has shifted right into the heart of the oil drilling and refinery area of the Gulf. <br /><br />The question we have to contemplate today is whether the market is becoming too hopeful over the potential damage from Rita. Prior to Katrina, we also saw a sharp dip in oil prices, but that quickly reversed when the reality of the repercussions came rolling in the following Monday. <br /><br />The market is always an interesting mix of emotions and more often than not it expects positive outcomes rather than negative. We see this quite often when a stock trades up prior to an earnings report or conference call. <br /><br />It would probably be better for the market if it was overly negative in front of the hurricane rather than optimistic. The emotional fallout is usually much worse when high hopes are dashed rather than when bad news doesn't turn out to be as bad as imagined. The market has a better chance of a sustained positive reaction when it overcompensated to the downside but then learns that it has been too pessimistic. <br /><br />If hope stays high today we have to seriously consider selling it. Despite what the academic literature tells us, the market is not good at accurately discounting future events. Market participants are too emotional of a group to be realistic about how things might unfold; they almost always are too extreme. <br /><br />The market would be a lot easier if we had continued weakness in front of the storm. We could then anticipate a relief rally next week. Unfortunately, too many people are thinking the same thing and they are all trying to jump in front of the move well before it even sets up. That is why we are seeing the strength yesterday and this morning. That strength is further bolstered by the folks who don't understand it but are loath to be left on the sidelines if the market is going to rally. <br /><br />We have a tricky day in front of yes, The market is opening close to flat, oil and gold down and overseas markets mixed. <br /><br />