Trading Tax Will Hit the Wrong Target<br />By Rev Shark<br />RealMoney.com Contributor<br />11/25/2009 8:22 AM EST<br /><br /> To be happy means to be self-sufficient.<br /> -- Aristotle<br /><br />The market is looking more upbeat this morning after some very dull trading action on Tuesday. The day before Thanksgiving is typically positive and it looks like we already have a little holiday spirit in the air.<br /><br />Technically the market is in pretty good shape. We were a bit overheated in the first hour of trading on Monday morning but have done little since then, so we have digested the move and have a little base of support to provide a foundation for some upside.<br /><br />The news wires are fairly quiet but we have quite a few economic reports coming up this morning, including weekly unemployment claims, durable goods orders, crude oil inventories and new home sales. Those reports should set the tone of trading. Market players seem to be looking for some positives so if we dip on the news I think we'll probably shrug it off fairly fast and bounce back, unless it is something quite dramatic.<br /><br />Speaking of unemployment, I was a bit shaken by Jim Cramer's support of a tax on trading "if it created new jobs." I doubt any tax has ever created more jobs than it has destroyed, especially when you have the government acting as a middleman and extracting its own pound of flesh.<br /><br />One of the things many people overlook in the discussion of a tax on trading is how different the market is today than it was before the Internet and all its associated technologies were developed. Trading has been greatly democratized over the years -- now just about anyone can be a trader and earn a living in the market if they have a little capital and are willing to work hard.<br /><br />Fifteen years ago you had to be live and work in one of the major financial centers if you wanted to be a "real" trader. There was no way someone like me sitting on the beach in Florida or the hills of North Carolina could participate in the market. Now we can all become self-sufficient if we have the desire and inclination to do so.<br /><br />The Internet made trading an even playing field, and as a result a major industry developed around it to assist the man on the street who wanted to participate in the markets. I know many individuals who now consider trading to be their primary job. They run small businesses that support them and their families, employ people and pay substantial taxes on their profits. Instead of using stock brokers, people now do research on their own using the many sites and tools available on the Internet, which has created productive businesses like TheStreet.com and RealMoney.<br /><br />When I hear the discussions about a tax on trading, it is clear that the politicians are after the big investment banks like Goldman Sachs or the irresponsible banks that helped to create the subprime crisis. I never hear any talk about how different the world of trading is now and how so many ordinary people look to the market as a way to produce income.<br /><br />A tax on trading will not only hurt the way the market operates, it will hurt many innocent individuals who never had any responsibility for the excesses of Wall Street in the first play and probably helped the market recover much faster than it would have otherwise.<br /><br />I hope that those who back a tax on trading figure out that they aren't just going to extract some fees form powerful institutions. They are going to hurt the lives of thousands of people on Main Street.<br /><br />I'm sure this issue is not going to go away quietly. I will continue to be a persistent and vocal advocate for individual traders who are at risk of becoming victims of short-sighted and ignorant politicians. <br />-----------------------------<br />Ülespoole avanevad:<br /><br />In reaction to strong earnings/guidance: QADI +14.3%, JCG +7.7%, TIF +7.0%... Select financial related names trading higher: IRE +3.0% (Bank of Ireland 5-year plan doesn't see more state aid - DJ), PUK +2.4%, BCS +2.0% (initiated with a Market Perform at Bernstein), DB +1.4%... Select metals/mining names showing strength: BHP +3.4% (MCC, Minara mull BHP mine bid - WSJ), BBL +3.3%, NG +3.1%, IAG +3.0%, HMY +2.8%, GFI +2.2%, GG +2.1%, RTP +2.0%, ABX +1.8%, AUY +1.8%, KGC +1.7%, GDX +1.6%, EGO +1.6%, MT +1.6%, GOLD +1.4%, NEM +1.2%, GLD +1.1%... Select overseas auto names ticking higher: HMC +4.5%, TM +2.3%... Select drug names showing strength: AZN +2.4%, SNY +1.6%, GSK +1.5%... Other news: INCY +16.6% (announces collaboration and license agreement for two hematology-oncology programs), HEV +10.7% (co's unit is supplying batteries for a major new smart grid program announced yesterday by the US Department of Energy), AIXG +4.5% (still checking), FLR +1.6% (Cramer makes positive comments on MadMoney)... Analyst comments: VPRT +2.2% (upgraded to Buy at Citigroup).<br /><br />Allapoole avanevad:<br /><br />In reaction to disappointing earnings/guidance: CONN -12.0%, DRAM -11.3%, CWTR -6.5%, DE -1.2%... Other news: CZNC -12.4% (priced 2.5 mln share common stock offering at $8/share), SAY -11.3% (India agency files more charges against 10 accused in Satyam scam - WSJ), PLA -5.9% (Distribution Services announces newsstand distribution agreement with Playboy Enterprises; note recent reports circulated that the co is in talks to be taken over), SQNM -5.7% (pulling back from yesterday's 30% pop), MAT -3.5% (trading ex dividend), AONE -2.8% (pulling back from yesterday's 15% jump), RMBS -2.1% (U.S. Patent Office rejects all 17 claims in three Rambus patents asserted against NVIDIA in International Trade Commission action), HAL -1.5% (announces a major reduction in activity from its primary customer in Mexico for Q4; impact is currently expected to be approx $0.02/share)... Analyst comments: GTE -2.6% (downgraded to Hold at Wunderlich).