Forget the 'Facts'<br />By Rev Shark<br />RealMoney.com Contributor<br />10/9/2009 8:53 AM EDT<br /><br /> The truth is more important than the facts.<br /> -- Frank Lloyd Wright<br /><br />Yesterday, in response to some questions posed by Doug Kass on The Edge, Anirvan Banerji and Don Dion set forth some bullish arguments in support of this very strong market. While I tend to share some of Doug's skepticism about the ability of this market to keep running, the very positive responses he received make me appreciate how there are always two sides to the market. There is never a time in the market when there aren't highly intelligent, logical and insightful arguments for either side.<br /><br />At times we are often inclined to dismiss those with views opposing our own as lacking insight and intellectual rigor. We will be tempted to dismiss them as not having a clear understanding of what is really happening. "How can those bulls not see what is so painfully obvious to us bears?"<br /><br />Of course those on the other side of the market will feel equally secure in their own beliefs. "This market is acting extremely well and is merely reflecting the many economic improvements to come. How can those foolish bearish not appreciate what is really happening out there?"<br /><br />Back and forth we go, and there will never be a shortage of proponents for whatever market case you want to make. We can line up two full football teams of highly respected pundits for both sides to battle back and forth, and neither is ever going to convince the other. The battle will always end in a murky tie until the market monster takes control and settles the debate.<br /><br />In the end there is no way to know which argument will win out, and even if you could know who will be proved right, you need to have the proper timing in order to really profit.<br /><br />My point here is that we always have to guard against being overly committed to one side of the market. Establishing who is "right" is an impossible task. All we really can do is monitor the action and try to react to it as it unfolds. Predicting how the market will act based on macroeconomic arguments is impossible. What will drive us will be emotions and feelings. Arguments about fundamentals only matter when certain conditions exists. Facts are a deceptive thing that will mislead us greatly if we don't understand the prevailing psychology of the market.<br /><br />So do the bulls or the bears have the better arguments about this market right now? I don't know. My bias is to be bearish, simply because my personal experience leads to me to believe that the economy is still in extremely poor shape and not improving much. On the other hand, the market is acting like that doesn't matter, and it would be arrogant of me to think I know more than the market. I'm left with no choice but to respect the bullish case here until the market says otherwise. If I want, I can find some folks to provide arguments to back up this price action, but the fact that the market is acting well is all the confirmation the bulls need at this point.<br /><br />We have a little softness this morning, but there isn't much going on out there at the moment. Google (GOOG) has an upgrade, but I don't see much else. <br />-----------------------------<br />Ülespoole avanevad:<br /><br />In reaction to strong earnings/guidance: SCIL +52.9% (thinly traded, light volume), RBC +3.1% ... M&A news: PSTA +11.8% (agrees to be acquired by Pulmuone for $2.70 per share in cash)... Other news: THLD +19.8% (Presents interim data from a Phase 1/2 clinical trial of TH-302), SRZ +11.5% (announces it has entered into an agreement to sell 21 wholly owned assisted living communities), HEB +6.7% (still checking), HTZ +6.4% (Cramer makes positive comments on MadMoney), SVNT +3.8% (priced underwritten offering of 4,300,000 shares of its common stock at a price of $13.29 per share; also upgraded to Outperform at Oppenheimer), MPEL +3.5% (still checking), NOK +2.1% and ERIC +1.8% (checking for anything specific), ELGX +2.0% (comments on alleged patent infringement)... Analyst comments: NTAP +4.1% (Solid analyst day guidance, macro demand improving - Merriman; upgraded to Buy at ThinkEquity), SE +3.6% (upgraded to Conviction Buy from Neutral by Goldman Sachs - DJ), AKS +2.6% (upgraded to Buy at Deutsche), TS +2.4% (initiated with Buy at UBS), LSI +2.0% (upgraded to Equal Weight from Underweight at Barclays Capital), RIMM +1.1% (upgraded to Outperform at Baird).<br /><br />Allapoole avanevad:<br /><br />In reaction to disappointing earnings/guidance: PCBK -7.3% (thinly traded, light volume), INFY -3.6%... Select metals/mining names showing weakness with dollar rebounding: GFI -2.7%, HMY -2.4%, BBL -2.3%, AU -2.2%, BHP -1.9%, GOLD -1.7%, KGC -1.5%, SLW -1.4%, AEM -1.4%, NEM -1.3%, AUY -1.2%, GDX -1.2%, VALE -1.1%, ABX -1.1%, GG -1.0%... Other news: SPPI -15.8% (receives complete response letter from FDA for FUSILEV in advanced metastatic colorectal cancer), ACOR -10.6% (announces posting of briefing documents for October 14 FDA Advisory Committee meeting on Fampridine-SR), LXRX -6.2% (priced a 33.33 mln share common stock offering at $1.50/share), HOGS -5.1% (announces common stock offering, made pursuant to an effective shelf registration), STXS -4.7% (Announces Public Offering of Common Stock of up to $25 mln), TTM -3.4% (raises $750 mln to pay Jaguar-Land Rover debt - DJ), LYG -2.6% and RBS -1.4% (Royal Bank of Scotland and Lloyds loan levels probed - FT)... Analyst comments: AKAM -3.2% (downgraded to Market Weight at Thomas Weisel), ARO -3.1% (cut to Sell from Neutral by Goldman Sachs - DJ), SVU -2.9% (downgraded to Equal Weight at Barclays), LTD -2.6% (downgraded to Sell from Hold at Soleil), EP -2.4% (cut to Neutral from Buy by Goldman Sachs - DJ), HOT -1.9% (downgraded to Hold at Soleil), POT -1.3% (initiated with Sell at Dahlman Rose), EPB -1.1% (cut to Buy from Conviction Buy by Goldman Sachs - DJ), MT -1.0% (downgraded to Hold at RBS), BMY -0.9% (downgraded to Neutral from Outperform at Cowen).