<br />http://www.nytimes.com/2002/01/09/business/09FUEL.html<br /><br />U.S. Ends Car Plan on Gas Efficiency; Looks to Fuel Cells<br /><br />By NEELA BANERJEE with DANNY HAKIM<br /><br />The Bush administration is walking away from a $1.5 billion eight- <br />year government-subsidized project to develop high-mileage gasoline- <br />fueled vehicles. Instead it is throwing its support behind a plan <br />that the Energy Department and the auto industry have devised to <br />develop hydrogen-based fuel cells to power the cars of the future, <br />administration and industry officials said yesterday.<br /><br />The new effort, to be announced in Detroit today by Energy Secretary <br />Spencer Abraham, aims at the eventual replacement of the internal <br />combustion engine. Fuel cells use stored hydrogen and oxygen from the <br />air to create electricity, and the only emission from engines they <br />power is water vapor.<br /><br />Environmentalists and some energy experts favor the research. But <br />critics said that the new program would let Washington and Detroit <br />focus on vague, long-term aims while avoiding the more difficult task <br />of improving the mileage of existing cars and sport utility vehicles <br />in the short term. Experts say that commercial production of cars <br />with fuel- cell engines is 10 to 20 years away.<br /><br />With hearings scheduled in the Senate next month on a Democratic <br />alternative to President Bush's energy program, it has been unclear <br />how either party will address fuel economy standards, which are <br />equally unpopular with carmakers and organized labor.<br /><br />Yesterday, an administration official speaking on the condition of <br />anonymity said that the Transportation Department would offer a <br />proposal later this year on tightening those standards. But he added <br />that since any changes would be years in the making, the fuel-cell <br />project could make them "a nonissue."<br /><br />The original program, begun in 1993, aimed to develop affordable cars <br />that got 80 miles to a gallon of gasoline. Vice President Al Gore, <br />its most vocal backer in the Clinton administration, likened the <br />project, known as the Partnership for a New Generation of Vehicles, <br />to the Apollo space program in its technological complexity. In <br />addition to about $1.5 billion in government subsidies, the Big Three <br />automakers - General Motors (news/quote), Ford Motor (news/quote) and <br />DaimlerChrysler (news/quote) - together spent about $1 billion a year <br />on related technologies.<br /><br />The carmakers all developed prototype vehicles that got at least 70 <br />miles a gallon, and the project nurtured advances in aerodynamics and <br />lighter composite materials now used in auto manufacturing.<br /><br />But none of the Big Three came close to commercial production of an <br />80-mile-a-gallon car. The average fuel economy of cars and trucks for <br />sale in the United States has, meanwhile, steadily dropped, so that <br />this year's fleet - with its growing proportion of sport utility <br />vehicles - gets the worst gas mileage in 21 years, according to the <br />government.<br /><br />The new program, called Freedom Car, will not require the automakers <br />to produce a fuel-cell powered vehicle, according to the Energy <br />Department. Energy experts expressed concern yesterday that without <br />such clear targets, it too would do little to alleviate the country's <br />growing dependence on oil.<br /><br />"I think fuel cells are a useful long- term goal," said Steven Nadel, <br />executive director of the American Council for an Energy Efficient <br />Economy, a research and advocacy group in Washington. "But the big <br />problem I have is that the Bush administration proposal doesn't seem <br />to address anything for the next 10 years. There's a lot of <br />technology that can go into cars in 2006 or 2007."<br /><br />The new initiative was disclosed yesterday by The Detroit News. The <br />administration said it would not discuss its proposed spending on the <br />project until President Bush's 2003 budget proposal was released in <br />February, but the program it replaces was to receive $127 million in <br />federal funds this year.<br /><br />Although gasoline prices are now low, the conflict in Afghanistan has <br />thrown a spotlight once more on America's enormous appetite for fuel <br />and has renewed calls for reducing American dependence on foreign <br />oil. The United States, with only 5 percent of the world's <br />population, consumes 25 percent of its oil, mostly in the form of <br />gasoline.<br /><br />Mr. Abraham, in remarks prepared for delivery today at the North <br />American International Auto Show in Detroit, said the new project was <br />"rooted in President Bush's call, issued last May in our National <br />Energy Plan, to reduce American reliance on foreign oil." He added, <br />"The eventual goal of this research are technologies that aim to <br />solve many of the problems associated with our nation's reliance on <br />petroleum to power our cars and trucks."<br /><br />While the Clinton administration program focused on developing high- <br />mileage family sedans - vehicles that fell out of favor with <br />consumers as the research progressed - Mr. Abraham said the new <br />project would give automakers the flexibility to use the fuel-cell <br />engines in a range of vehicles.<br /><br />"We should be developing energy- efficient components that can be <br />adapted for use in several models throughout our fleet," he said.<br /><br />The stocks of several companies that are developing fuel cells surged <br />yesterday on news of the administration initiative. Shares in Ballard <br />Power Systems (news/quote), probably the best known of these <br />companies, jumped 15 percent, to $34.96. FuelCell Energy (news/quote) <br />rose 22 percent, to $21.85; Plug Power was up 39 percent, to close at <br />$12.04.<br /><br />The Big Three automakers are expected to introduce so-called hybrid <br />vehicles, using gasoline-electric engines, by 2004. Toyota <br />(news/quote) and Honda - which did not share in the Clinton-era <br />program's subsidies - already have hybrids getting at least 40 miles <br />a gallon.<br /><br />The auto industry has steadily resisted government-mandated increases <br />in fuel economy, with some carmakers arguing that such requirements <br />would divert investment from fuel-cell research. Government <br />standards, unchanged for more than a decade, require each automaker's <br />cars to average 27.5 miles a gallon and light trucks - including <br />pickups, minivans and sport utility vehicles - to average 20.7 miles <br />a gallon.<br /><br />Kara Saul Rinaldi, the deputy policy director for the Alliance to <br />Save Energy, a bipartisan advocacy group in Washington, said that she <br />welcomed the investment in fuel cells but hoped the administration <br />would explore improvements in fuel-economy standards. "We're looking <br />at long-term technology when we haven't made the first step," she <br />said. "Raising fuel-economy standards is the first step."<br />