Wise just bein´ regular Wise again. <br/><br/><br/>Wise avaldas eile endale tüüpilisel teemal uuringu, ehk pangad on pahad ja koorivad raha saatjaid. <br/><br/><a target="_blank" href="https://majandus.postimees.ee/7743689/wise-euroopa-pangad-varjavad-jatkuvalt-piiriuleste-maksete-tasusid">Wise: Euroopa pangad varjavad jätkuvalt piiriüleste maksete tasusid</a><br/>Sama infot ka Wise´ enda temaatilisel veebilehel: <a target="_blank" href="https://wise.com/community/cbpr2-enforcement">Banks are (still) hiding fees</a>. Seal on Belgia, Eesti, Ungari, Leedu, Hispaania, Saksamaa ja UK pankade kohta teinud ülevaated kui palju pangad erinevatesse valuutadesse saates erinevaid varjatud tasusid koorivad. <br/><br/><blockquote>What’s the purpose of this report?<br/><br/>According to the EU’s Cross-Border Payments <br/>Regulation, providers need to inform a customer “prior <br/>to the initiation of the payment transaction, in a clear, <br/>neutral and comprehensible manner, of the estimated <br/>charges for currency conversion services applicable <br/>to the credit transfer”.<br/>This report shows that despite these rules, banks still <br/>hide the bulk of the cost of a transfer in an inflated <br/>exchange rate. The rate they offer their customers is <br/>much worse than the rate you see on Google. We’ve put <br/>two screenshots side-by-side to expose these fees and <br/>show consumers get a worse deal than they think.<br/></blockquote><br/><br/><a target="blank" href="https://lienzo.s3.amazonaws.com/images/8660dfee32b2cbb36d0c48cc52464da5-Estonia%20Hidden%20fees%202022%20(2).pdf">Eesti kohta</a> (PDF) vaatasid HUF, PLN ja RON saatmist Swedbanki, Luminori ja SEB veebipankades. Loomulikult tulemus oli kole, ehk pangad koorivad hästi kõvasti: <br/><br/><img src="//fp-live-discourse-bucket.s3.dualstack.eu-north-1.amazonaws.com/original/3X/4/d/4ddd90b4e390eb4f5e5554d5d9175cc65ea2134d.png"/><br/><br/>Pangad nüüd vastavad: <a target="_blank" href="https://arileht.delfi.ee/artikkel/120166286/valeinfo-eesti-suurpankade-sissetulekute-kohta-swedbank-nad-tahtsid-naidata-end-paremast-kuljest">Valeinfo Eesti suurpankade sissetulekute kohta. Swedbank: nad tahtsid näidata end paremast küljest</a>. <br/><br/>Pangad ütlevad, et info on vale, kuna tegelikult tööpäeval valuutavahetust tehes on kursid panga veebilehel olemas, suuremad kui 10 000 EUR vahetused on parema kursiga, maksete paketiga on Euro ülekanded Ungarisse tegelikult tasuta ja mingeid ülekandetasusid pole, segi on aetud mitu teenust - valuuta konverteerimine ja ülekandeteenus ja kuvatud neid koos kallimana, valitud on Eesti jaoks sihilikult sekundaarsed ja väikese aktiivsusega valuutad millede puhul ongi kurss ebasoodsam, jne. <br/><br/>Kokkuvõttes Wise leidis endale sobiva nurga ja ketras jätkuvalt sedasama "Aga pangad on pahad", plaati. See kõik kõlab tuttavalt, kus ma seda küll juba varem kuulnud olen? <br/><br/>Äkki SaveOnSend blogi artiklis <a target="_blank" href="https://www.saveonsend.com/transferwise-money-transfer/">TransferWise (aka Wise): Rebel, What is Your Cause?</a><br/>Nt: <blockquote>As you can see, TransferWise was conveniently comparing its pricing with banks’ wire transfer service (similarly, it conveniently compares its online pricing with Western Union’s offline service). You might remember from the earlier comparison table that no provider was charging such large fees for sending money to India. And what were the top competitors’ exchange rates around the same time? Western Union – 61.98, MoneyGram – 62.21, Xoom – 61.5, Ria – 62.17, TransFast – 61.9. Hence, with the ads you saw above, by referring to “money transfer companies” instead of “banks” and claiming to be “the cheapest… to India”, TransferWise knowingly misleads consumers while shamelessly berating competitors for being “unfair” and “hiding.” We requested TransferWise to stop such practice, but to no avail:</blockquote><br/><br/>Ja: <blockquote>TransferWise has clearly been much stronger at execution than other startups (see this SaveOnSend article). But the biggest mystery remained: why does TransferWise feel the need to cut corners while berating competitors and generating fakes, like this ironically titled fake map of “real-time” transactions?<br/><br/>… or listen to this Fintech Insider podcast from October 2017 where TransferWise managers promote its new price comparison tool. They claimed that even if TransferWise’s pricing was not the best, the tool would transparently point a user to the cheapest provider. How did this tool really work? It made up a wrong-higher price for Western Union and didn’t show other competitors with better-than-TransferWise prices:<br/></blockquote><br/><br/>Ja: <blockquote>… or listen to this Fintech Insider podcast from October 2017 where TransferWise managers promote its new price comparison tool. They claimed that even if TransferWise’s pricing was not the best, the tool would transparently point a user to the cheapest provider. How did this tool really work? It made up a wrong-higher price for Western Union and didn’t show other competitors with better-than-TransferWise prices:<br/>...<br/>No improvement for years despite tripping the transfer volume. A sensible explanation would be to acknowledge management mistakes, apologize for setting unrealistic expectations, or share details about entering sub-scale corridors. But deviating from a PR message is not a TransferWise style. Instead, again for some inexplicable reason, TransferWise decided to blame everything on poor forecasting of one-time switching cost to AWS.</blockquote><br/><br/>Jne, jne. jne. <br/><br/>Ehk loominguline lähenemine tõele ja asjaoludele, see on olnud pikalt Wise´ stiil. <br/><br/><br/>Üks huvitav puänt on veel, mida tõenäoliselt paljud kohe ei taba. <br/><br/>Samal uuringu koondelehel üritavad vist viral turundust teha ja kutsuvad inimesi pankadega Twitteris pahandama: <br/><br/><img src="//fp-live-discourse-bucket.s3.dualstack.eu-north-1.amazonaws.com/original/3X/6/7/6761602cbcd2d5920b75c97baea9590c39cd7420.png"/><br/><br/>Call them out on Twitter link tekitab Twitteris postituse tekstiga "Why are you hiding fees in the exchange rate YOURBANK. You Can´t do this under EU law. #HiddenFees". <br/><br/>Pealtnäha ju tore strateegia, tõmbab esiteks viral tähelepanu kõigi postitaja jälgijate hulgas, teiseks aga uputab panga sõnumid mingi pahatahtliku vigisemise sisse ja kolmandaks tõmbab regulaatorite tähelepanu ja lühistab sellega konkurentide tegutsemist. <br/><br/>Milles on uba? Kus on puänt? <br/><br/>Tundub, et Wise on salaja mingi strateegiaotsuse vastu võtnud ja eemalab vähegi eksootilisematest paikadest kliente. Või siis on teatud kliendid eksinud kasutajalepingu vastu. Või siis on teatud kliendid teatud kohtades lihtsalt kõrgema riskiprofiiliga, nt. elavad Lähis-Ida maades kus terroriste on rohkem ja seega ongi nendega rohkem häda. <br/><br/>Anyway, olgu põhjused mis nad on, Twittter ja Facebook on täis pahaseid inimesi kes kõik süüdistavad Wise sellest, et Wise on nende raha ära varastanud, et Wise on scam company, et Wise on nende konto kinni pannud, et Wise hoiab juba kuude kaupa suuri summasid kinnid, et kümme miljonit korda on nad saatnud emaili või helistanud ja mingit abi pole kunagi saanud ja kõik saadavad mingile finantsteema ombudsmanile kirju, ähvardusi ja kaebusi Wise vastu ja nõuavad regulaatori tähelepanu. <br/><br/>:D <br/>:D <br/>:D <br/><br/>Valik värskeid näiteid: <br/><br/><a target="_blank" href="https://twitter.com/usama288/status/1641838507625676806">Hädas kasutaja</a>: <br/><img src="//fp-live-discourse-bucket.s3.dualstack.eu-north-1.amazonaws.com/original/3X/d/1/d15f61ba8ee9d431f53f957e886364e63a8dcf2e.png"/><br/><br/>Samalt: "Avoid ever using @Wise - the worst bank in the world."<br/><br/>Veel: "I am minding my business and @Wise suddenly shuts down my account, and tell me they cannot tell me why. They ask me to appeal, but what am I supposed to appeal? I have no idea what the problem is. I tell them that, and they reply that I am not clear enough, I should appeal again."<br/><br/>Veel: "It's my belief that banks like @Wise systematically discriminate against Africans. I.e, they don't look at the merits of the case, they just look if the person has African ties, and then shut down accounts. There are too many stories about this."<br/><br/><br/><a target="_blank" href="https://twitter.com/buka4rill/status/1640286713028198402">Palgaraha lihtsalt kinni kusagil</a>: <br/><img src="//fp-live-discourse-bucket.s3.dualstack.eu-north-1.amazonaws.com/original/3X/2/b/2b1fd63c52dc7aabcf79dd09836aa461cbcb1125.png"/><br/><br/><br/><a target="_blank" href="https://twitter.com/markessien/status/1641713903963873282">Veel üks "lojaalne ja rahulolev klient"</a>: <br/><img src="//fp-live-discourse-bucket.s3.dualstack.eu-north-1.amazonaws.com/original/3X/f/f/ff319ed65abcc52bfa0c442fc4570b232d8ac64e.png"/><br/><br/><br/><a target="_blank" href="https://twitter.com/oladaporich/status/1641839468695912455">Järjekordne NPS skoori kasvataja ja muidu rahulolev klient</a>: <br/><img src="//fp-live-discourse-bucket.s3.dualstack.eu-north-1.amazonaws.com/original/3X/d/7/d71a2e65b987a715caef3696c5a8e9ec38bba4f0.png"/><br/><br/>Jne, jne, jne. <br/><br/>Mulle tundub hoopis, et Wise soovib enda sarnaselt probleemilt tähelepanu kõrvale juhtida ja üritab teistele pankadele sama realasuse tekitada, ehk sotsiaalmeedia kanalid on täis pahaseid kliente, kes kõik oma pankasid nagu Wise´gi varastamises ja scammimises süüdistavad. <br/><br/>Nii palju siis uuringutest ja konkurentide võrdlemisest. <br/><br/>Kes end lõbustada soovivad, siis Twitteris otsingud @Wise ja @Taavet on konstantne funfest.